வெள்ளி, 18 ஆகஸ்ட், 2017

அம்பேத்கர் மொழிவழி மாநிலம் அமைய எதிர்ப்பு

aathi tamil

<aathi1956@gmail.com>
15 ஏப்ரல், 2017 ’அன்று’ பிற்பகல் 3:12
பெறுநர்: aathi1956@gmail.com
Gunaseelan Samuel
AMBEDKAR WAS AGAINST LINGUISTIC STATES AND WAS FOR HINDI IMPOSITION ON
NON-HINDI PEOPLES
DR. BABASAHEB AMBEDKAR WRITINGS AND SPEECHES VOL. 1, Compiled by
Vasant Moon, First Edition by Education Department, Govt. of
Maharashtra : 14 April, 1979 Re-printed by Dr. Ambedkar Foundation :
January, 2014, Pages 145-46.
“Having stated the advantages of a linguistic State I must also set
out the dangers of a linguistic State.
“A linguistic State with its regional language as its official
language may easily develop into an independent nationality. The road
between an independent nationality and an independent State is very
narrow. If this happens, India will cease to be Modern India we have
and will become the medieval India consisting of a variety of States
indulging in rivalry and warfare.
“This danger is of course inherent in the creation of linguistic
States. There is equal danger in not having linguistic States. The
former danger a wise and firm statesman can avert. But the dangers of
a mixed State are greater and beyond the control of a statesman
however eminent.
“How can this danger be met ? The only way I can think of meeting the
danger is to provide in the Constitution that the regional language
shall not be the official language of the State. The official language
of the State shall be Hindi and until India becomes fit for this
purpose English. Will Indians accept this ? If they do not, linguistic
States may easily become a peril.
“One language can unite people. Two languages are sure to divide
people. This is an inexorable law. Culture is conserved by language.
Since Indians wish to unite and develop a common culture it is the
bounden duty of all Indians to own up Hindi as their language.
“Any Indian who does not accept this proposal as part and parcel of a
linguistic State has no right to be an Indian. He may be a hundred per
cent Maharashtrian, a hundred per cent Tamil or a hundred per cent
Gujarathi, but he cannot be an Indian in the real sense of the word
except in a geographical sense. If my suggestion is not accepted India
will then cease to be India. It will be a collection of different
nationalities engaged in rivalries and wars against one another.
“God seems to have laid a heavy curse on India and Indians, saying ‘Ye
Indians shall always remain divided and ye shall always be slaves !’
“I was glad that India was separated from Pakistan. I was the
philosopher, so to say, of Pakistan. I advocated partition because I
felt that it was only by partition that Hindus would not only be
independent but free. If India and Pakistan had remained united in one
State Hindus though independent would have been at the mercy of the
Muslims. A merely independent India would not have been a free India
from the point of view of the Hindus. It would have been a Government
of one country by two nations and of these two the Muslims without
question would have been the ruling race notwithstanding Hindu
Mahasabha and Jana Sangh. When the partition took place I felt that
God was willing to lift his curse and let India be one, great and
prosperous. But I fear that the curse may fall again. For I find that
those who are advocating linguistic States have at heart the ideal of
making the regional language their official language.
“This will be a death knell to the idea of a United India. With
regional languages as official languages the ideal to make India one
United country and to make Indians, Indians first and Indians last,
will vanish. I can do no more than to suggest a way out. It is for
Indians to consider it"

அம்பேத்கர் மொழிவழி பிராந்திய அதிகாரங்கள் எதிர்ப்பு

aathi tamil

<aathi1956@gmail.com>
15 ஏப்ரல், 2017 ’அன்று’ பிற்பகல் 3:13
பெறுநர்: aathi1956@gmail.com
Gunaseelan Samuel
Ambedkar preferred Unitary form of Government and was against
Provincial Autonomy!
DR. BABASAHEB AMBEDKAR WRITINGS AND SPEECHES VOL. 1, Compiled by
Vasant Moon, First Edition by Education Department, Govt. of
Maharashtra : 14 April, 1979 Re-printed by Dr. Ambedkar Foundation :
January, 2014, Page 353.
“I am not opposed to a Federal Form of Government. I confess I have a
partiality for a Unitary form of Government. I think India needs it.
But I also realize that a Federal Form of Government is inevitable if
there is to be Provincial Autonomy, But I am in dead horror the
Federal Scheme contained in the Government of India Act. I think I
have justified my antipathy by giving adequate reasons, I want all to
examine them and come to their owe conclusions. Let us however realize
that the case of Provincial Autonomy is very different from that of
the Federal Scheme. To those who think that the Federation should
become acceptable if the Governor-General gave an assurance along the
same lines as was supposed to be done by the Governors that he will
not exercise his powers under his special responsibilities I want to
say two things. First I am sure the Governor-General cannot give such
an assurance because he is exercising these powers not merely in the
interest of the Crown but also in the interest of the States.
Secondly, even if he did, that cannot alter the nature of the Federal
Scheme. To those who think that a change in the system of State
representation from nomination to election will make the Federation
less objectionable, I want to say that they are treating a matter of
detail as though it was a matter of fundamental. Let us note what is
fundamental and what is not. Let there be no mistake, let there be no
fooling as to this. We have had enough of both. The real question is
the extension and the growth of responsibility. Is that possible ?
That is the crux. Let us also realize that there is no use hugging to
Provincial Autonomy and leaving responsibility in the Centre hanging
in the air. I am convinced that without real responsibility at the
Centre, Provincial Autonomy is an empty shell. What we should do to
force our point of view, this is no place to discuss. It is enough if
I have succeeded in giving you an adequate idea of what are the
dangers of this Federal Scheme.”
This is what the RSS is doing now!
4 மணிநேரம் · பொது


  தலித் அரசியல் மறுபக்கம்

 

விமர்சனம் தலித் குணா

கருத்துகள் இல்லை:

கருத்துரையிடுக